A record-breaking £14bn collective action against Mastercard is set to rumble on after the former financial ombudsman who brought the case on behalf of 46 million consumers seeks to appeal last month’s Competition Appeal Tribunal ruling.
Law firm Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, which represents Walter Merricks CBE, announced today it has applied to the tribunal for permission to appeal the decision.
Boris Bronfentrinker, a partner at the firm, said: “Together with Mr Merrick’s team of highly experienced barristers, we have carefully analysed and considered the tribunal’s judgment and identified a number of manifest errors in the reasoning and approach of the tribunal.”
“As the first mass consumer collective action, and given the size of the class, complex issues have been raised that the English courts have not had to consider previously.”
Ruling in Walter Merricks CBE v MasterCard Inc and Others, Mr Justice Peter Roth dismissed the claimant’s application to certify the proceedings under the Competition Act 1998. The tribunal accepted Mastercard’s arguments that, even if loss had been suffered and could be estimated across the whole class, there was no way of ensuring that a class member would receive distribution of an amount compensating any actual loss suffered.
The case was one of the first to be brought under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, which provides for so-called ‘opt-out’ collective proceedings on behalf of a class of individuals.
Quinn Emanuel said today there was ‘legal uncertainty’ on whether there is a direct right of appeal to the Court of Appeal, or whether the case needs to go to the administrative court for a judicial review.
Former financial ombudsman Merricks said he is ‘pleased’ that the fight will continue. “In filing the application, the next step has been taken in what could be a long fight” he said.
It has recently come to our attention that Diamond Resorts International are writing directly to our clients making offers to… Read More
LEISURE DIMENSIONS LIMITED - MGM - PETCHEY LEISURE - MUTHU HOTELS - CLUB INFINITI If you are a timeshare owner… Read More
RESORT DEVELOPMENT ORGANISATION (RDO) --- WE’RE TURNING UP THE HEAT!!! Our readers might remember our article - RESORT DEVELOPMENT ORGANISATION (RDO)… Read More
SAND AND SEA RESORTS UNLAWFULLY RIPPING OFF UK CONSUMERS We have recently been approached by a client who encountered Sand… Read More
Timeshare Talk - The Anonymous Timeshare Trolls are Out In Force – FedUpMum - Charlie1 We have been made aware of… Read More
TATOC 2015 – Dealing with Claims Companies RDO advice to resort owners when dealing with Claims Companies: “The letters from… Read More
This website uses cookies.